John Halligan tells 'arrogant' ministers ‘shut up’ over refusal to pay water bills

A defiant John Halligan has told “arrogant” Fine Gael ministers to “shut their mouths” and leave him and his fellow independent minister Finian McGrath alone over their refusal to pay water charges.

Mr Halligan, TD for Waterford, is expected to be named a junior minister in the Government by Taoiseach Enda Kenny next week, but was bullish in his defiance of Fine Gael calls for himself and Mr McGrath to pay their water bills.

Mr Kenny and several Fine Gael ministers called on Mr McGrath to pay his water bills. Speaking to the Irish Examiner, Mr Halligan singled out comments by new chief whip Regina Doherty over the weekend as most unhelpful.

Mrs Doherty advised TDs who haven’t paid their water bills to do so as they won’t “magically disappear”.

“I don’t know what they are at. They should have shut their mouths on it and consulted with us first. It is only creating tension and showing a type of arrogance again,” he said. He argued Fine Gael knew his position and of Mr McGrath in relation to water charges during the negotiations.

Mr Halligan said he hasn’t paid any water charges as he hasn’t been billed, but that he is opposed to the principle of paying water charges.

“It is interesting in that I haven’t even been billed. I wouldn’t pay it anyway being honest.

“I think there is two issues. When they were negotiating this Programme for Government with us and ministerial positions, they knew our positions on this, well. It is also a newly structured Dáil with the whip being removed on votes of conscious and so on. We are only obliged to support the Government on votes of confidence and the budget,” he added. “When they were offering Finian McGrath a ministry, they knew he hadn’t paid his water charges, he had been saying it in the Dáil,” the Waterford TD said.

Mr Halligan said for him the decision to back Enda Kenny was difficult enough without this sort of conflict, as he has some people already calling him a “traitor” for entering Government, even though he won concessions on Waterford Hospital.

Last night, Mr Kenny joined the chorus of Fine Gael ministers who called on Mr McGrath to pay his water charges.

“Yes, he should pay his water charges, of course,” the Taoiseach said at an event in Dublin city centre.

Earlier, ministers Simon Harris and Paschal Donohoe led the charge by saying they expected a fellow minister to comply with the law of the land and pay his charges.

Mr McGrath released a statement through the Department of Health, in which he said he would seek advice as to his non-payment of water charges.

“Minister McGrath is getting advice from the Attorney General and will be consulting with his Independent Alliance colleagues,” the statement said.

Original article: Daniel McConnell and Juno McEnroe, Irish Examiner, May 12, 2106

Irish Water: Thousands cancel direct debits amid uncertainty

Ralph Riegel and Paul Melia

Thousands of Irish Water customers have moved to limit their exposure to financial loss in the light of ongoing discussions about the future of water charges.

The Irish Independent has learnt there has been a flood of cancelled direct debits in the last number of weeks as Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil were embroiled in government formation talks.

Irish Water is refusing to release the exact figures, saying they are not available at this time, but sources have suggested that up to 80pc of all calls involve customer queries over repayments, direct debit cancellations and refunds to their bank accounts.

One source said people were desperate to recoup some of their payments made to date.

"I'd estimate that eight in 10 calls now involve people questioning direct debit cancellations, refunds or how exactly the SEPA banking refund system works," the source said.

"Last year there was significant anger over the bills. But at the moment people just seem to want information about how they can get some of their money back."

Irish Water last night declined to comment on the scale of direct debit cancellations it has faced since the 2016 General Election and the confusion over water charges.

One utility official said it does not comment on "hearsay".

However, the number of payment cancellations is understood to now be running to thousands each week. It is also believed the numbers cancelling have increased amid repeated warnings from major political parties that there is no question of immediate refunds for the 928,000 households who have paid their charges to date.

More than 1.5 million water bills are currently being issued, with some 750,000 expected to be posted or sent electronically over the coming weeks. The bills are being sent because Irish Water is legally obliged to continue to charge for water and wastewater services, and customers are expected to pay under current legislation. New legislation will be enacted after a minority government is formed, which is likely to be next week, after which charges will be formally suspended for at least nine months.

It has also emerged that Irish Water workers and contractors are also seeking emergency meetings with Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil and the Independents over the implications of the deal on the suspension of charges on their jobs.

Aside from its directly employed staff, Irish Water's operation provides employment for more than 1,000 contractors both in terms of meter installation and bill processing.

More than 750 specially trained contractors operate with Cork outsourcing firm, Abtran, on handling Irish Water bills and payments. Contractors are also involved in the installation of water meters and various maintenance functions.

Separately, the chair of the Public Water Forum has said that neither Fianna Fáil nor Fine Gael made contact with the group over the agreement struck between both parties in relation to the water charging issue.

Dr Tom Collins, (photo above)  who chairs the forum which is designed to address consumer concerns, said he saw the value of an entity which would advise on best practice. He said in education, the National Council for Curriculum and Assessment (NCCA) was tasked with helping to shape policy, and that could be helpful in the water debate.

"They (the parties) didn't talk to the forum," he said. "I could see the value of an organisation in relation to developing proposals for drinking water and wastewater, and not just confined to Irish Water."

Original article:   Irish Independent May 5, 2016


The battle of Irish Water. Another reason to heed protesters.

By James Quigley,  part one of a two part article

 

This article centers around Irish Water Ltd.  It questions the political, economical and social agendas of the some of the playmakers behind the multi billion euro project and criticises the ever growing influence they have on the Irish political system. 

The first article is a more generalised synopsis of what I believe are serious issues of political and social manipulation surrounding the setting up of the semi state Irish Water company.  The second article will be more specific and will zone in on some of the playmakers' involvement in the saga,  an elitist club of academics, professionals and multinationals forging what could be described as the equivalent of a masonic fellowship.

 


The 'one-arm bandit'  may seem a bit misleading. It suggests an Irish system as a game of chance. However, the reality could not be further from the truth. What one hand giveth, the other taketh away. All gaming machines in fact are rigged. Gambling generally is manipulated to give the owners the upper hand, the odds and permutations are studied to give optimal profit. They are calculated to draw you in, keep you hooked but extract as much cash as they can. Otherwise they would not be in business. Everything looks legit but in reality it is an illusion, a trick, the razmataz of tinsel town.

 

Largest project in history of the state

In 2014 Bord Gáis Éireann described Irish Water in a submission to the Joint Oireachtas Committee on the Environment as “one of the largest reform projects in the history of the State”.

Another interesting report and one which is at the heart of this discourse, 'Delivering Ireland's Water Services for the 21st Century' was prepared in 2011 by The Irish Academy of Engineering and Engineers Ireland. . It was presented to the Oireachtas, by Mr Gerry Grant, Managing Director, RPS.  Incidentally Mr Grant is now Managing Director of Irish Water Ltd.

It is not what the report advises that is important but it is the members of the report's taskforce that is revealing. It includes  RPS, Engineers Ireland, Irish Academy of Engineers,  State and Co Council employees and various individual private consultant firms.  We will focus on these groups in the second part of this article.  However, this group represents a quintessential example of the establishment joining forces with multinational corporations to set or influence the political and social agenda.  

This multi billion euro Irish Water project,  with approx €11bn of assets and nearly the same again in running costs, has indeed unearthed a can of worms.  Intrigues abound. Not only is it because of the vast amount of money involved but probably more so because Irish Water is what has been described as the 'largest reform project in history' that has attracted the interest of a myriad of multinational corporations along with  indigenous entrepreneurs and academics. Like a herd of sharks,  they have tasted the potential of this bonanza.

To some the Irish Water project may be  Shangri-La but to a lot of Irish people  it epitomises how our political, economical and social system has been systematically manipulated by global and indigenous interests for their own ends.

From Irish Water's embryo stage some 16 years ago right through to the Troika supervised formation stage,  2012-2014, to the present day political impasse,  Irish Water Ltd has a history of secrecy, controversy and  political manipulation.  It has seen the  involvement of  high powered multinational corporations and local Irish businesses  in the affairs of the state.  It is this relationship between the establishment, politicians, local businesses, academics and partisan group and  multinationals corporations  that is the driving force behind the Irish Water project.  It is this relationship that is at the heart of the controversy where one could nearly describe the outcome as a coup. 

The methods and techniques used by these elite forces are insidious, pervasive and relentless.  Because of present day economics Governments and countries are entrapped by the lure of employment and a quick GDP fix. It is a catch 22 situation where the elite use politicians and vice versa politicians use multinationals corporations to further each others agendas. Instead of pursuing quality of life, self sufficiency and indigenous employment we are sucked into a dependency of multinational corporations.  These corporations are by their very nature  transitory, adversarial, secretive and self-serving and extremely powerful. They have no allegiances other than the stock markets and profits. Barriers to trade and borders are broken down,  political systems are manipulated and politicians bought and sold.  

 Cultural diversity and political systems are harmonised to attain 'economy of scale', the be all and end all of the their economic structure. We all have to be the same, automatons, with the same needs and outlook in order to service this multinational imperialistic megalomaniac machine.


Great legions of lobbyists

Nothing as far as possible is left to chance, apart, of course, from the roulette wheel of the stock exchange.  Countries, political systems, market trends and the public have all been thoroughly assessed, researched and analysed. A methodology and model is developed to conquer the market.  Many of these corporations and even individuals have ready access to more cash than individual countries.

All our political, legal, educational institutions are used to further multinational corporations'  goals . Great legions of lobbyist, solicitors, engineering, planning and economic advisers are employed to copper-fasten their agenda.

The illusion of democracy and freedom is churned out through the controlled media, puppet politicians and omnipotent public relations firms. We are led to believe that all the endeavours are for the citizen's own good and the benefit of society.   There is never any mention of the vast profits to be made or the  control of political systems.  The public are constantly fed the idea of democracy and are told that they have a choice, a say in their affairs.  Half truths and diversions hide the fact that the illusion of democracy comes around every 5 years where we dutifully hand over the levers of power to political prostitutes and the sugar daddies. It is a merry-go-round, a house of mirrors, flashing lights and the jingle of change. Maybe we might walk away with the teddy bear or maybe nothing at all.

Ireland, it's people and it's politicians have been thoroughly assessed, surveyed, our habits and markets researched and analysed.  The elite have produced a model and a methodology to suit their philosophy. Such a model is Irish Water Ltd and an unmerciful propaganda war is now raging to consolidate the company and philosophy into the Irish system.

 Multinational  feast, of course, done through a competitive procurement process

Bord Gáis was chosen to oversee this project. In their 2014 submission to the Joint Oireachtas Committee they stated “Bord Gais was given a mandate to establish Irish Water as a key part of the water reform programme. We set out for Government our approach for delivering Irish Water back in January 2012......... Bord Gáis set out clearly, from the outset, that while the core capability to define what was required to establish Irish Water existed within Bord Gáis, it would require the use of specialist service providers to help implement this programme. In essence the Bord Gáis team in conjunction with secondees from the Local Authorities and the Department specified what was required. Bord Gáis used its experience and its existing systems and processes to define the requirements for Irish Water. ”  

The external services  and the costs were: IBM €44.8m, Accenture €17.2m, Ernst & Young €4.6m and KPMG €2.2m.

Up to 2014 Bord Gáis spent  the guts of €2bn including the above expenditure, their own running costs and that of the metering contracts of over €1.2bn. All metering contracts went to outside multinational companies including  Murphy Group, Coffey Northumbrian Ltd and GMC Sierra.  GMC Sierra a subsidiary of the infamous and former Siteserv, (now Actavo).  Last year Eurostat calculated that Irish Water expenditure to be €800m per year over a 8 year period until 2021. This figure will probably reach €1bn per year.   Incidentally there is no mention in the report of the Siteserv controversy or the offer made by Siemens to provide meters at a much cheaper price.  No everything was above board and contract awarded  "through a competitive procurement process".

Bord Gáis Éireann has since been split up, the lucrative part privatised and sold to Centrica plc in 2014. The unprofitable part is now called Ervia, a semi state company. Irish Water Ltd, apparently is a subsidiary of Ervia. Even Eurostat, an EU statistical office was not able to define the make up of Irish Water Ltd. Isn't it ironical that Bord Gáis the parent company who used it's own model as a template for Irish Water has been privatised and sold off. A bad omen for the future.

So you believe we have a democracy?

A quote from Ernst & Young, one of the external corporations hired by Bord Gáis in 2012 to set up Irish Water, “We have one strong global leadership team that sets one single global strategy and agenda. To ensure we are efficient and effective, we have organized our legal entities into 28 similarly sized business units, called Regions, in terms of both people and revenues. These Regions, almost all of which are purposely not single countries, are grouped into four geographic Areas:” 

What is Democracy?

According to political scientist Larry Diamond, democracy consists of four key elements:

(a) A political system for choosing and replacing the government through free and fair elections; (b) The active participation of the people, as citizens, in politics and civic life; (c) Protection of the human rights of all citizens, and (d) A rule of law, in which the laws and procedures apply equally to all citizens.

Democracy, he says, “must improve where it already exists before it can spread to other countries.  He believes solving a country’s governance, rather than its economy, is the answer. Every democratic country needs to be held responsible for good governance, not just when it suits them."

"Without significant improvements in governance, economic growth will not be sustainable.  For a democratic structures to endure – and be worthy of endurance – they must listen to their citizens’ voices, engage their participation, tolerate their protests, protect their freedoms, and respond to their needs.” The Spirit of Democracy

Shane Ross magnificent Dáil speech

Irish Water symbolises what is so wrong with Ireland today and so wrong with this government. It embraces so many wrongs and so many attitudes that so many recent that it has united unusual and unlikely forces against this government and Irish Water” he goes on to admonish the government of political appointments to the board of Irish Water.”  Shane Ross, 2014, Dáil Éireann

 

Eddie Hobbs Deep State

Democracy in Ireland partially exists every few years at election time when politicians and media make a little fuss and somehow cajole you into believing their myths. What they do not tell you or you don't seem to get is that you really do not have any power. Real power only exist in what Mr Hobbs calls 'Deep State'.”  Buncrana Together

 

Can the battle for democracy be won?

Taking on such a force may seem futile.   However, there is a chink in the elites' armour, an Achilles' heel.  This vulnerability is the absolute arrogance,  the flaunting of power, wealth and prestige, the condescension  and the manipulation of political processes and not least corruption.  Coupled with that there is a massive upsurge inpopular protest in Ireland against what is seen as corruption and wanton neglect.  It is this political awareness, the amount of contempt and the anger against the Irish Water project and the forces behind it that has the potential to put a stop to the elite's plans.

Somehow democracy has to be salvaged and wrested from the grips of the power brokers. The last stand could be the battle against Irish Water Ltd.   If the Irish Water model succeeds then it would be fair to say that corruption and anti democratic forces will have achieved their goals.

Bord Gáis 2014 Submission to Oireachas: https://www.water.ie/news/bord-gais-expertise-to-sa/Irish-Water-Submission-to-Joint-Oireachtas-Committee-14th-January-2014.pdf

Irish Academy of Engineers and Engineers Ireland report: Delivering Irelands Water Services for 21st Century