EU to take action over State’s ‘dangerous’ drinking water

Republic faces infringement proceedings due to the presence of chemicals in its supply

‘THMs are carcinogenic chemicals formed when chlorine is added to purify water.’ Photograph: Getty Images/iStockphoto

The European Commission will take infringement proceedings against Ireland due to dangerous levels of chemicals found in drinking water.

The commission wrote to the Department of Housing this month confirming that a pilot case it had initiated into the level of trihalomethanes (THMs) in the water system has been closed.

In the correspondence, it confirmed that further “treatment” would now be necessary to deal with the chemicals, which have been linked to cancer.

A spokesman said the commission would now move to take “more formal steps” in response to ongoing concerns.

Sources confirmed that infringement proceedings would begin within a matter of weeks.

Ireland will be given the opportunity to respond to the action. If its response is inadequate, the commission can take the case to the European Court of Justice, whose judgment is binding.

Significant daily penalties could be imposed by the court if Ireland does not act appropriately.

THMs are chemicals that have been present in many public water supplies for years. They are formed when chlorine is added to purify water.

 

Long-term exposure is reported to carry increased risks of cancers, including of the bladder and colon, and causes damage to the heart, lungs, liver, kidney and central nervous system.

Limited levels

Permissible levels of trihalomethanes in drinking water are limited by the EU drinking water directive and World Health Organisation guidelines.

It is understood that up to 400,000 households in Ireland are affected, including ones in parts Kerry and Cork, Kilkenny city, Waterford, Wicklow, Meath, Mayo, Roscommon, Donegal and Galway.

In May 2015, the European Commission initiated a pilot case here due to THMs levels exceeding guidelines in some drinking water supplies.

A spokesman for the Department for Housing confirmed that correspondence had been received and said it would co-operate fully with the commission.

“Irish Water, working closely with the Department of Housing, Planning, Community and Local Government, has developed plans and programmes to address these THM exceedances where they have arisen,” he said.

“These plans were communicated to the commission as part of the response to the pilot case.

“The commission informed the department last week that it has closed the pilot case but with the intention of further treatment.”

Irish Water said it was unaware of the commission’s response, but the company has already committed to addressing areas with THM by 2021.

Its business plan sets out a clear commitment to reduce the number of all schemes on the agency’s remedial action list, including those affected by trihalomethanes, “to zero”.

Source: Sarah Bardon, Irish Times, Jan 30 2017


 

Buncrana Together

The wheels of European bureaucracy turn very slow. 

One would think that there should have been more urgency considering the deadly consequences of the carcinogenic cocktail in our drinking water, especially in Donegal, one of the more neglected areas in Ireland and in particular Greencastle where levels of thrihalomethanes exceeds accepted levels.  We were told that this was going to be fixed by 2017 .    Many of our articles show the minimising arguments made by Irish health and Government officials. 

Mr Tony Lowes, Friends of the Irish Environment,  said"this decision has come six years after we first brought the issue to the Commission's attention".  He pointed out his article ' Ireland's Poisoned, Dirty water: the cover-up' written by himself and Malcolm Coxall in 2011.

See http://buncranatogether.com/home/2016/2/18/the-emerald-isles-pure-clear-waters-are-swimming-in-carcinogenic-trihalomethanes?rq=trihalo


Ireland passes law to become world's first country to fully divest from fossil fuels

Ethical financing shows global corporations that their tactics are no longer tolerated, says Deputy Pringle

Bill will drop coal, oil and gas investments from Ireland Strategic Investment Fund

Ireland has voted to be the world’s first country to fully divest public money from fossil fuels.

The Irish Parliament passed the historic legislation in a 90 to 53 vote in favour of dropping coal, oil and gas investments from the €8bn (£6.8bn) Ireland Strategic Investment Fund, part of the Republic’s National Treasury Management Agency.


The bill, introduced by Deputy Thomas Pringle, is likely to pass into law in the next few months after it is reviewed by the financial committee.

Ireland has voted to be the world’s first country to fully divest public money from fossil fuels.

The Irish Parliament passed the historic legislation in a 90 to 53 vote in favour of dropping coal, oil and gas investments from the €8bn (£6.8bn) Ireland Strategic Investment Fund, part of the Republic’s National Treasury Management Agency.

The bill, introduced by Deputy Thomas Pringle, is likely to pass into law in the next few months after it is reviewed by the financial committee. 

“This principle of ethical financing is a symbol to these global corporations that their continual manipulation of climate science, denial of the existence of climate change and their controversial lobbying practices of politicians around the world is no longer tolerated,”  Mr Pringle said.

“We cannot accept their actions while millions of poor people in underdeveloped nations bear the brunt of climate change forces as they experience famine, mass emigration and civil unrest as a result.”

Once enacted, the bill would force the Ireland Strategic Investment Fund to sell its investment in fossil fuel industries over the next five years.

In 2015, Norway’s sovereign pension fund divested from some fossil fuel companies, but not all. 

 

Source: www.independent.co.uk Jan 27 2017


Jury awards $10.5 million in punitive damages in DuPont cancer case

By Earl Rinehart
The Columbus Dispatch  •  Thursday January 5, 2017 6:35 PM

Craig Holman | Dispatch file photo
DuPont's Washington Works chemical plant on the Ohio River

Jurors who awarded an Ohio man $10.5 million in punitive damages Thursday apparently heeded his attorney’s call to punish DuPont for causing his cancer, and to send a message to corporate America.

"It's important to punish, to end this corrupt corporate mentality," attorney Gary J. Douglas urged the jury in U.S. District Court in Columbus.

The amount was the largest awarded of three DuPont cancer cases tried so far in Columbus.

After the verdict, Douglas said of DuPont, "One would hope, depending on how callous they are, with compensatory damages of seven figures and punitive in eight figures, when they're looking at 3,000 cases, they would do the right thing."

That, he said, would be a mass, "global" settlement with the plaintiffs.

The same jury awarded the plaintiff, Kenneth Vigneron, 56, a truck driver from Washington County, $2 million in compensatory damages last month.

Vigneron said his drinking water was tainted by C8, a chemical used to make Teflon, from smokestack emissions at DuPont's Washington Works plant. The particles settled on the Little Hocking Water Association well fields, eventually contaminating the water supply.

The plant is along the Ohio River in Parkersburg, West Virginia.

Jurors also had found that DuPont acted maliciously because it knew in the 1960s that C8, or perfluorooctanoic acid, was toxic and a cancer risk, but said nothing publicly until forced to by lawsuits and regulators.

The jury returned to court on Wednesday to hear both sides argue how much to give Vigneron, who suffered from testicular cancer. His attorneys didn't ask for a specific number; a DuPont attorney asked for "zero," saying the company already has paid enough for its "mistake."

Douglas told jurors DuPont has a "staggering" $18.8 billion that can be converted to cash, including $4.5 billion in cash and other sources. A plaintiff witness, forensic economist Robert Johnson of California, said the company has net sales of $68 million a day.

“That $2 million in (compensatory) damages, they make in 42 minutes,” Douglas said.

Johnson said he studied DuPont’s corporate financial statements and documents filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. He said a single award of $100 million would allow DuPont stockholders to still receive a dividend and "no one has to lose his job."

Financial observers have said DuPont is concerned about how one large punitive damage award affects the thousands of remaining suits it faces.

Of the two previous trials in Columbus, one jury awarded a woman with kidney cancer $1.6 million in compensatory damages, but said she was not eligible for punitive damages. The other jury awarded a man with testicular cancer $5.1 million in compensatory damages and $500,000 in punitive damages.

U.S. Chief District Judge Edmund A. Sargus Jr. heard the three C8 cases and will preside at the next one, which also involves testicular cancer, beginning Jan. 17. In May, several federal judges will hear C8 cases in Ohio, Kentucky and West Virginia. The goal is to hear 270 cancer cases at the rate of 40 cases over 10 months every year.

DuPont attorney Craig Woods told jurors the company regrets what happened, but that "DuPont has paid for their mistake. It doesn't deserve to be punished on top of that."

The company said it spent $594 million to clean up C8 problems. That included $70 million for a community health study in 2005, $20 million to build state-of-the-art water filtration systems at all six public water districts affected, and millions for a science panel that in 2012 said there was a probable link between the chemical and several types of cancer.

"This money was committed for doing the right thing," DuPont attorney John Gall told the jury of three women and three men.

DuPont is expected to appeal the verdict.

C8 no longer is used to make Teflon, a product that now belongs to a DuPont spinoff called Chemours Company. Chemours issued a statement after Thursday's verdict: "In the event DuPont claims it is entitled to indemnification from Chemours as to some or all of the judgment, Chemours retains its defenses to such claims.”

Chemours stock closed Thursday down 33 cents, or 1.5 percent, at $21.88. DuPont stock fell 36 cents, or .50 percent, at $73.81.

Source: The Columbus Dispatch, Jan 5 2017